March 9, 2021
Combined Reporting: A Widely Used Tool to Counter Corporate Tax Avoidance
Schools with good teachers, well-maintained streets, access to high-quality health care – these basics help communities to thrive. Yet Virginia’s current system of raising resources to invest in thriving communities allows too many corporations to avoid paying their fair share. During the 2021 General Assembly session, state lawmakers approved further legislative study and consideration of a corporate tax reform known as “mandatory combined reporting.” This policy is a key tool to counter tax avoidance strategies that large, multi-state corporations engage in, and which 28 states and the District of Columbia have already adopted. The policy improves the fairness of the tax code by putting multi-state corporations on a more level playing field with locally-based corporations. In addition, because mandatory combined reporting has been so widely adopted, many large corporations that operate in Virginia are already accustomed to following this policy. Analysis of publicly available information shows that 79 of Virginia’s largest corporations by employment operate in at least one jurisdiction that already uses combined reporting. This analysis suggests that combined reporting is unlikely to be a major factor in corporate location decisions.
The Commonwealth Institute would like to acknowledge and extend sincere thanks to Michael Mazerov, Senior Fellow at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, for technical assistance for this project.
The governor and legislature should take up and enact this important reform in next year’s session.
Virginia currently taxes corporate profits at a flat 6% rate. However, for corporations that operate across many states, the amounts reported to and taxable in Virginia are based on multiple adjustments that depend on their operating structures, their particular industry, and other factors. In the current state tax landscape, large, multi-state corporations can use accounting maneuvers and exploit weaknesses in state tax structures to reduce their state income tax liability, which strains state budgets. In states without mandatory combined reporting policies, corporations can relatively easily shift profits to other states that tax corporate income at lower rates – or that do not tax corporate profits at all. As one example, a manufacturing corporation could set up subsidiary companies in low-tax states as suppliers of factory inputs. The parent company can then pay the subsidiary an artificially high price for those inputs, which are then deducted as a business expense, reducing the parent company’s tax liability.
To counter these kinds of practices, 28 states and D.C. require corporations to file tax returns under a mandatory combined reporting framework. In these states, corporations must add up all of the income from the parent company and most or all of its subsidiaries. If adopted in Virginia, the member corporations doing business in the state would report the appropriate share of their combined profit on their state tax returns, negating many common tax avoidance strategies.
New analysis of corporate locations
An analysis of 83 large employers in Virginia that are multi-state corporations and likely subject to Virginia’s corporate income tax shows that:
- 79 operate in at least one combined reporting jurisdiction
- 71 operate in multiple combined reporting jurisdictions
- 51 operate in at least 10 combined reporting jurisdictions, including Amazon, Booz Allen Hamilton, CarMax, Home Depot, Lowes, Raytheon, UPS, Target, and Walmart.
(For more information, please see the methodology note below)
This analysis suggests that combined reporting is unlikely to be a major factor in where corporations decide to locate. In addition, many of the largest employers in Virginia are not subject to the state corporate income tax, including federal agencies and other government entities, nonprofit health systems, certain public service corporations that pay separate state fees or taxes, insurance companies that are subject to Virginia’s Insurance Premiums License Tax, and certain banks that are subject to Virginia’s bank franchise tax. Adoption of combined reporting in Virginia would have no direct impact on those employers.
State policymakers face key state budget choices around K-12 education funding, health care, public health, and other priorities in the decade ahead. To adequately invest in these services will require a strong state revenue system where wealthy individuals and large corporations pay their fair share. Combined reporting can be a critical tool for strengthening the state’s corporate tax system. According to state estimates, enacting combined reporting in Virginia would likely result in substantial new state revenues, with recent estimates ranging from $60 million to $80 million per year.
Advancing racial equity in the tax code
All policy, including tax policy, has different impacts on people by race and can either advance racial justice or further injustice. Policies like combined reporting would likely also reduce racial inequality because of the stark racial disparities in who tends to own shares of stock (and in what amounts) for Black and Latinx households relative to white households.1 Research also suggests that state corporate income taxes are largely taxes on wealth because most of the tax is ultimately paid by capital owners or land owners.2 Median wealth among white households is eight times greater than median wealth among Black households and five times greater than that of Latinx households according to the most recent data from the Federal Reserve, which pre-dates the impacts of the recession.3
While this policy would not address the barriers to wealth that Black and Latinx households face by itself, it could help, particularly if state leaders choose to use the additional resources with that goal in mind. Historical and present-day barriers related to housing, education, employment, and other areas helped to create and continue to contribute to the racial wealth divide. Adopting racially equitable policies to support additional public investments would help to build greater opportunity more broadly across the state.
Tax fairness for small and local businesses
As Virginia policymakers consider options to assist small and local businesses, improvements to the corporate tax code can create a more balanced tax system with respect to businesses. Enacting combined reporting would end an unfair tax advantage that large corporations have over locally-based corporations and other businesses without out-of-state subsidiaries. In terms of tax fairness, this reform would put businesses on a more level playing field.
During and after the last recession, Virginia policymakers closed some tax loopholes and reduced certain tax breaks, but did not fully restore state funding levels in key areas like K-12 education and higher education by the time this latest recession began. By instituting mandatory combined reporting, the state would gain resources that could be used to strengthen public education and other building blocks of thriving communities, while improving the fairness of Virginia’s tax code. State legislators and the governor must work together on a better approach to fuel an equitable recovery that makes the public investments that are needed. Strengthening the state’s corporate tax code needs to be part of the solution.
Table: Large Virginia Corporate Employers Adhere to Combined Reporting Across the U.S.
|Va. large employer||Total||AK||AZ||CA||CO||CT||DC||HI||ID||IL||KS||KY||ME||MA||MI||MN||MT||NE||NH||NJ||NM||NY||ND||OR||RI||TX||UT||VT||WV||WI|
|Administaff (now Insperity)||15||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|AdvanSix (Honeywell spinoff)||1||✔|
|Air Serv Corp (ABM Industries)||27||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Beacon Roofing Supply Inc.||28||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Booz Allen Hamilton||19||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|BWX Technologies Inc.||1||✔|
|Canon Virginia Inc.||25||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Corporate Executive Board (owned by Gartner)||5||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Dollar Tree Inc.||27||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Estes Express Lines||28||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Food Lion (owned by Ahold Delhaize)||13||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Gannett Co. Inc.||25||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|General Dynamics Corp||25||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Graham Holdings Co.||21||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|GTT Communications Inc.||7||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Hamilton Beach Brands||0|
|HCA Virginia Health System||9||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc.||1||✔|
|Hooker Furniture Corp.||1||✔|
|Huntington Ingalls Industries, Inc.||22||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|ICF International Inc.||16||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Kings Dominion (part of Cedar Fair)||4||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Leidos Holdings Inc.||25||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Lowes’ Home Centers, Inc.||29||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Lumber Liquidators (now LL Flooring)||26||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|ManTech International Corp.||22||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Norfolk Southern Corp.||12||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Owens & Minor Inc.||16||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Parks Hotel and Resorts (Chesapeake Lodging Trust)||11||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Performance Food Group Co.||16||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|PRA Group, Inc. (Portfolio Recovery Associates)||3||✔||✔||✔|
|Qurate Retail (QVC Suffolk, Inc.)||7||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Ruppert Landscape (part of Ruppert Companies)||1||✔|
|Science Applications International Corp.||20||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Smithfield Packing Company (Owned by Chinese Conglomerate WH Group)||14||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Strategic Education Inc.||8||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|SW Rodgers Company||0|
|TE Connectivity, Ltd.||6||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|The Brink’s Company||20||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|The Home Depot||29||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
|Trex Co. Inc.||1||✔|
|United Airlines Inc||28||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔||✔|
TCI staff compiled a list of large employers in Virginia using information on major employers found on the websites of the Virginia Employment Commission, Virginia Business, and local and regional economic development entities. TCI also attempted to determine the extent to which employers were subject to the Virginia corporate income tax by reviewing applicable federal laws, the Code of Virginia, and nonprofit tax filings published by ProPublica.
For the employers that are structured as corporations that are likely subject to Virginia corporate income tax, TCI staff reviewed, to the extent available, those corporations’ 10-K filings with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, annual reports, and corporate websites and job listings, and other public information to determine other states where those corporations operate.
- Choudhury, S., “Racial and Ethnic Differences in Wealth Holdings and Portfolio Choices,” Division of Economic Research; Office of Research, Evaluation, and Statistics; Office of Policy; Social Security Administration, 2002
- Suárez Serrato, J.C., & Zidar, O., “Who Benefits from State Corporate Tax Cuts? A Local Labor Markets Approach with Heterogeneous Firms. American Economic Review.” This paper estimates that 65%-70% of state corporate taxes fall on business owners or land owners http://gabriel-zucman.eu/files/teaching/SuarezSerratoZidar16.pdf, 2016
- Bhutta, N., Chang, A.C., Dettling, L.J., & Hsu, J.W., “Disparities in Wealth by Race and Ethnicity in the 2019 Survey of Consumer Finances,” FEDS Notes, Washington: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Sep 28, 2020